top of page

If It's Been Sitting, Something Must be Wrong with It? Fact or Fiction.

2 minutes ago
6 min read
Child in a white hat peers over a wooden fence with binoculars, watching outdoors on a sunny day.

Have you ever watched a house sit on the market for months and thought, There must be something wrong with it?


Or maybe you liked it, but decided to wait. Surely the seller would drop the price eventually.


Then one day it disappears. A few weeks later, the sale records, you see the number, and think, Wait. That’s what they took? I would have paid that. Or, Damn. Somebody got a good deal. Or maybe, Well, I guess the sellers finally got sensible.


Maybe they did. Or maybe somebody finally made them an offer.


Let’s unpack that.


A house sitting on the market tells you one thing with certainty: it has not yet sold on the terms being offered. It does not tell you why.


It may be:

  • overpriced;

  • priced appropriately, but the people who would buy it have not been shopping during the time it has been available;

  • poorly photographed or poorly presented;

  • marketed in a way that does not communicate why somebody should pay what the seller is asking;

  • difficult to understand online;

  • much better in person than it looks in the listing;

  • appealing to a relatively small group of buyers;

  • carrying an objection buyers have noticed and the seller has not fully absorbed;

  • or, yes, actually problematic.


It could smell. It could be falling down. There could be a ghost. This is New Orleans. I am not ruling anything out.


But days on market will not tell you which one of those things is true.


Yellow traffic light on a pole against a blue sky, with the bottom green light lit and the top two lights dark.

You have to go find out.


And if what you are thinking is, I like it, but not at that price, there is a good chance you are not alone in that understanding. In fact, you may have competition. Huh?


Check the saves.


You may be watching that house while ten, twenty, or thirty other people are watching it too, all thinking some version of the same thing. That matters because one of the most common things buyers tell us is, I’ll wait until they drop the price.


Okay. To what? For what? Why?


If a house is listed for $700,000 and you would gladly buy it for $665,000, what exactly are you waiting for? The seller to independently arrive at $665,000, list it in the MLS, and announce it to you and everyone else who has been watching?


The price reduction you are waiting for does not make the house cheaper only for you. It may be exactly what gets everybody else off the sidelines too.


Meanwhile, the seller may be having a completely different conversation.


The buyer is thinking, They’re asking too much. I’ll wait. But the seller may be sitting at their kitchen table asking their agent, Where are my offers?


Plenty of sellers come to market believing they need room to negotiate. Others have spent a lot of money improving their property and understandably believe the market will return those dollars one for one. Sometimes it will. Sometimes those improvements were simply necessary to make the property competitive with everything else buyers could choose.


Empty wooden park bench in a sunny park, with a green hill and autumn-colored trees under a bright sky.

And sometimes an agent knows the price is ambitious but does not want to lose the listing, so everybody agrees to try it.


Then they try it.


And the market responds with silence.


That silence does not necessarily mean the seller has decided they will never accept less. It may simply mean nobody has actually put less in front of them.


That is where an offer becomes useful.


We have helped buyers purchase properties for $20,000 below asking, $35,000 below asking, more than $60,000 below asking, and yes, once, more than six figures below asking. That is not about “getting the other guy down.” The point is not to beat the seller. It is to figure out whether there is a deal both people are willing to make.


A listing says, I'd sell my house on these terms.


An offer says, I would buy your house on these terms.


Usually the deal happens somewhere in the middle.


Once an offer is made, the conversation begins.


Now there is something to respond to. Maybe the seller says no. Maybe they counter. Maybe it becomes immediately clear that the buyer and seller are nowhere near each other. Maybe there is a deal sitting somewhere between the two numbers. Maybe the seller says yes.


All of those outcomes tell you more than another month of watching the listing.


None of them result in being told off face to face. None of them result in your name being published in a public list of people out of their minds. And none prevent you from trying again, including on the same property.


Let's unpack the truth.


In our market, most homes ultimately close at more than 95 percent of their latest list price.


Latest is doing a lot of work in that sentence.


A house can start at $750,000, sit, reduce to $725,000, then $699,000, then $675,000, and eventually close at $660,000. Someone looking only at the final list-to-sale ratio sees a house that sold for almost 98 percent of asking.


That is true.


But the real story is the drop from $750,000 to $660,000. During the time on the market, the seller had already been hearing from the market through every reduction before an actual buyer ever entered the conversation.


So why wait for the market to do the work for you? While making it easier for your competition, too.


Blurred cyclist riding past bright yellow city lights at dusk, creating a fast, energetic motion effect.

Why don't things move?


Sometimes the price is the problem. Sometimes the house has been sitting because the buyer pool is small.


A conventional three-bedroom house at a common price point may have a large pool of potential buyers. A giant historic property, an unusual commercial conversion, a condo with a very specific use case, or anything else that requires a particular person may not.


If that person was not shopping during the first 60 days, 60 days on market does not automatically establish that something is wrong with the property.


Sometimes the marketing is the problem. Sometimes buyers simply do not see enough value relative to the price. And sometimes they see it perfectly well and still believe the seller is asking too much.


That is useful information too.


How to make it work for you.


Privately thinking, I would buy this for $50,000 less, does not help the seller understand where the market actually is. Writing the offer might.


We watched another version of this happen recently with a lovely couple from California who dreamed about relocating to the French Quarter. Craig found them a condo on Governor Nicholls. They were skeptical. The pictures were not helping.


It would have been extremely easy to look at the listing, look at how long it had been available, look at those photographs and think, If it were actually good, somebody would have bought it already.


Instead, they went to see it.


Turns out the listing was not the house.


They bought it.


The reverse happens too. The buyer makes the offer. Seller says no. Sixty days later, seller says, Are those buyers still interested?


Happens all the time.


Though, by then, the buyer has often moved on.


Woman lying on a coral bed doing a yoga pose with legs up, in a bright bedroom with abstract wall art and pillows.

What we do about it.


We start buyers out window-shopping the MLS before we ever need them to make an important decision. We will pull up properties that have already sold and ask:


Would you have paid this for that? What about this one? Would you have stretched another $20,000 for the yard? Would parking have been worth it to you? What about the location? The extra bedroom? What is worth stretching for, and what absolutely is not?


Those are much easier questions to answer before you are emotionally attached to a house and already mentally arranging the furniture.


We are trying to understand how you value things.


Because once you know that, list price stops being an instruction. It is a starting point.


Then, when an actual property comes along, we can stop asking the abstract question, Is $700,000 too much? and ask a far more useful one: What is this house worth to me?


And if the answer is less than the seller is asking, you do not necessarily need to wait around hoping they eventually guess your number.


You can tell them.


If you would buy the house for $665,000, make the $665,000 offer. Let the seller decide whether they want to talk. Maybe they do. Maybe they don’t. Maybe they don’t today and call back 60 days from now.


But do not wait for the MLS to negotiate for you.


Because the next time a house you have been watching finally closes and you look at the sale price and think, Whoa. That was a good deal. Damn. I would have paid that. Geez, I guess the sellers finally got sensible — remember that there may be a much simpler explanation.


Maybe you would have paid that.


The seller just never knew.


Somebody else told them first.


Smiling woman in black top and burgundy skirt holds open book titled Prepped to Sell in a wood-paneled room.

Celebrated for her next-level creative approach to real estate, Elisa Cool Murphy is the author of Prepped to Sell: What Works Even When the Market Doesn't. She is an award-winning, top-performing real estate broker in New Orleans and the founder and owner of Cool Murphy Real Estate.



Contact Her -

Facebook: @homeinneworleans

IG: @coolmurphynola

YouTube: @coolmurphynola

phone: 504-321-3194

Comments


Cool Murphy, LLC consists of licensed REALTORS® in the state of Louisiana. Our brokerage is modern and cloud-based with mailing addresses at 904 St Ferdinand St, New Orleans, LA 70117. We serve the Greater New Orleans area and are happy to refer great agents in other places.

Our office number is 504-321-3194.

​

© 2022 by The Narrative. 

equal-housing-opportunity-logo-1200w.png
bottom of page